RT Article T1 Reason with Baggage JF Journal of religious ethics VO 47 IS 4 SP 696 OP 715 A1 Milevsky, Jonathan LA English PB Wiley-Blackwell YR 2019 UL https://www.ixtheo.de/Record/1687340005 AB In this article I show that David Novak's natural law theory precedes his encounter with Judaism. That is to say, the theory is the product of a theological viewpoint consisting of three components—createdness, commandedness, and response—that is then found by Novak in a number of areas of Jewish thought and practice that admit of the same three parts. As a result of this interpretation, I posit that Paul Nahme, who argues for a pragmatic reading of Novak's theory, as well as Martin Kavka and Randi Rashkover, who offer a political understanding of it, do not account for the theological richness and metaphysical basis of Novak's natural law theology. K1 David Novak K1 Jewish-Christian dialogue K1 Metaphysics K1 Natural Law K1 Theology DO 10.1111/jore.12287